The college football season is heating up, and a handful of handicappers are proving why they sit atop the leaderboards. After four weeks of action, the numbers don’t lie—some experts are delivering consistent profits, high ROI, and sharp win percentages.

For bettors looking to ride the hottest streaks, all of these experts’ premium and free picks can be found at PicksDepot.com. And remember—no matter whose side you’re on, always shop for the best lines with OddsLogic to maximize value.

1. John Ryan – The Clear #1

  • Profit: $1,132
  • ROI: +37.1%
  • Record: 20-8 (71.4% Win Rate)

John Ryan has set the gold standard entering Week 4. His blend of data-driven analysis and situational trends has him hitting over 71% of his college football plays. With a stellar ROI north of 37%, Ryan has been the single most profitable capper on the board. Bettors tailing him from opening weekend are already sitting on four figures of profit.

2. Info Cash Picks – Consistency Pays

  • Profit: $1,043
  • ROI: +23.6%
  • Record: 26-14 (65.0% Win Rate)

Info Cash Picks is living up to the name—turning information into money. Their balanced portfolio of plays has cashed at a 65% clip, racking up over $1,000 in profit. For those who prefer steady returns with solid volume, this group has been rock solid.

3. Sean Higgs – Grinding Out Wins

  • Profit: $752
  • ROI: +9.8%
  • Record: 39-29 (57.4% Win Rate)

Sean Higgs is proving that high volume doesn’t mean sacrificing quality. With nearly 70 plays released already, he’s not just treading water—he’s beating the market with a near 10% ROI. For bettors who like action across the Saturday slate, Higgs has delivered.

4. Brooke Bennett – A Sharp New Name

  • Profit: $685
  • ROI: +17.5%
  • Record: 22-14 (61.1% Win Rate)

Brooke Bennett is quickly emerging as a force on the leaderboard. With discipline and a keen eye for line value, Bennett has produced a 61% win rate through three weeks. Her $685 profit and 17% ROI show she’s not just a flash in the pan.

5. Freddy Wills – Back in the Spotlight

  • Profit: $678
  • ROI: +17.0%
  • Record: 22-14 (61.1% Win Rate)

Freddy Wills has long been respected in betting circles, and 2025 is shaping up as another banner year. He’s neck-and-neck with Bennett, showing identical records and nearly identical profits. Those who’ve followed Wills know he thrives in the midseason grind—making him one to watch moving forward.

Other Notable Movers

  • Big Al McMordie – $627 profit, a steady veteran delivering at nearly 59%.
  • Stephen Nover – Smaller sample (11-5), but his 68.8% hit rate and +31.8% ROI stand out.
  • Rob Vinciletti – $512 profit with a 61.5% win rate, proving once again why he’s a trusted name.

Key Takeaways for Bettors

  1. John Ryan and Info Cash Picks have separated themselves at the top, combining profit with elite win percentages.
  2. High volume bettors can lean on Sean Higgs, while sharp value seekers should keep a close eye on Brooke Bennett and Freddy Wills.
  3. Don’t just follow the picks—maximize your edges. A half-point here or a better moneyline there makes a massive difference over the course of the season. That’s why experienced bettors use OddsLogic to line shop every wager.

Final Word

College football is a long season, but after four weeks, the cream is already rising to the top. Whether you’re riding the heater with John Ryan, cashing steady with Info Cash Picks, or backing sharp emerging names like Brooke Bennett, you can grab all the top plays right now at PicksDepot.com.

And remember—winners get paid not just by picking the right side, but by getting the best number. Make sure every ticket counts by shopping with OddsLogic before you lock in your bets.