The NFL season is hitting its stride, and so are the handicappers at PicksDepot.com. Whether you’re looking for premium picks or want to sample the free picks, the leaderboard speaks volumes about who’s been delivering the profits so far this year.

Below we break down the top NFL handicappers for 2025 entering Week 4, ranked by profit, ROI, and win percentage.

🚀 Elite Performers

1. Info Cash Picks

  • Record: 7-0 (100%)
  • Profit: $700 | ROI: +90.2%
  • Avg. Odds: -111
  • Highlight: The only capper with a perfect record heading into Week 4. A flawless 7-0 start makes Info Cash Picks the gold standard so far this season.

2. Timothy Black

  • Record: 12-6 (66.7%)
  • Profit: $541 | ROI: +25.6%
  • Avg. Odds: -111
  • Highlight: A long-term veteran showing consistency again. His 12 wins already have backers stacking profits.

3. John Ryan

  • Record: 13-8 (61.9%)
  • Profit: $428 | ROI: +18.8%
  • Avg. Odds: -108
  • Highlight: Known for analytics-driven selections, Ryan’s steady ROI and high win rate make him a trustworthy option week after week.

📈 Rising Stars

4. Kiev O’Neil

  • Record: 14-9 (60.9%)
  • Profit: $415 | ROI: +16.3%
  • Highlight: O’Neil’s strong volume combined with efficiency puts him among the best in the business.

5. Calvin King

  • Record: 8-4 (66.7%)
  • Profit: $369 | ROI: +26.3%
  • Highlight: A sharp eye for value, especially at shorter odds, has King climbing the leaderboard quickly.

6. Joseph D’Amico

  • Record: 7-3 (70.0%)
  • Profit: $366 | ROI: +31.4%
  • Highlight: One of the best ROI percentages in the group, proving fewer plays with sharper edges can pay off.

⚡ Consistent Winners

7. Kevin Young – 10-6, +$362, +21.3% ROI
8. Black Widow – 10-6, +$342, +19.9% ROI
9. Mr. East – 10-6, +$321, +17.9% ROI
10. Frank Sawyer – 13-9, +$315, +13.0% ROI

This group rounds out the top 10 with profitable and consistent results, giving bettors multiple proven options depending on style and volume.

🏈 Middle of the Pack, Still Profitable

  • Steve Janus (11th): +$248 profit, 61.5% winners.
  • Bobby Wing (12th): +$231 profit, steady 57.9% hit rate.
  • AAA Sports (13th): +$228 profit, 60% record.
  • Ray Monohan (14th): +$103 profit, 12-10 record, grinding out wins.

Even those outside the top 10 are still producing profits — a testament to the depth of talent at PicksDepot.

⚖️ Breaking Even but Competitive

Names like Zack Cimini, Doug Upstone, Marc Lyle, and Andrew Gold have shown small but steady profits. A strong Week 4 could catapult them back into the top tier.

📍 Where to Get the Picks

All of these cappers’ plays — both free picks with analysis and premium best bets — are available now at PicksDepot.com.

  • Free Picks: Great for bankroll building and seeing each capper’s style.
  • Premium Picks: Backed by full analysis and best-in-show confidence ratings.

Final Word

With the NFL season heating up, following the right handicapper can make all the difference. Whether you ride the perfect streak of Info Cash Picks or the long-term reliability of Timothy Black and John Ryan, Week 4 offers plenty of opportunities.

👉 Check out PicksDepot.com today for all the top NFL picks — both free and premium — and see why it’s become the go-to hub for sharp bettors in 2025.